Crossovering 2014

[galfridian]

Welcome to Crossovering, a multi-fandom crossover exchange!

Nominations for fandoms will open May 24, so be thinking about all those greats crossovers you've been dying to read/write.

If you have any questions, please ask them here!

Comments

[sirvalkyrie]

I'm a little concerned with the amount of fandoms required to participate. Going by the faq you need at least six fandoms to participate. While with eight nominations that seems doable, but with the cut at top hundred or so fandoms and no real idea on what is needed to get a fandom in that seems like a steep order especially for anime/manga fans.

How will complicated fandoms be treated?

[galfridian]

To address the issue of what's needed to get a fandom in: The top 100 fandoms with the most nominations. That's all. The only other approaches we could think to limit the number of fandoms involved genre (sci-fi, crime, etc) or borrowing from other exchange's eligible lists.

We realize this complicates the exchange for some people, and we're sorry for that fact, but unfortunately, the nature of this exchange demands it.

Before I can answer your question about complicated fandoms, can you tell me what you mean? I want to say you're referring to fandoms that cross multiple genres (like Marvel and its comics/cartoons/MCU), but I want to be sure I know what I'm addressing.

[sirvalkyrie]

Here are a few examples...

Doctor Who - Will it all be treated as one fandom? Will there possible be multiple fandom slots taken up by it
Final Fantasy - Would it be treated as a whole, by continuity, by entry?
Power Rangers - It is all in continuity with each other but fandom typically treats it by season name rather than as a whole
Precure - Except for the two sequels, each season is treated as a different continuity

So when will a continuity be grouped together or separated out. If say Power Rangers Zeo, Power Rangers Lost Galaxy and Power Rangers Samurai don't have enough nominations individually to get into the top 100, but combined they do would they just be out right rejected or would they be accepted as a single fandom?

[galfridian]

I think we'll address those on a case-by-case basis. Several fandoms, like Doctor Who and Marvel Cinematic Universe, make sense as one fandom. Some fandoms make more sense as unique fandoms.

That said, we welcome any input from people familiar with fandoms like those you listed. We're not familiar with most of them, so we won't presume to know what works best for any of them. We'll go with the consensus for each fandom like it during nominations.

And yes, we will consider combining smaller fandoms into a larger fandom if they would make it into the Top 100 together. Again, we will do this on a case by case basis. If more people would rather have all of them together than none at all. Of course, if we get fewer than 100 fandoms, everything nominated will also make it in.

[beaslays]

Regarding Final Fantasy, each entry has a wildly different setting and set of characters from the others, so a crossover with Final Fantasy 7 would be really different from a crossover with Final Fantasy 4. Fandom also typically treats entries as separate from each other, except in the case of sequels and other same-continuity entries. Crossovers between the different entries are usually specified as being crossovers.